This weeks ten focuses on the worst draft picks in Wisconsin sports History.
Honorable Mention:
Vinnie Clark: Packers, 1991
Darrell Thompson: Packers, 1990
Antuan Edwards: Packers, 1999
Yi Jianlian: Bucks, 2007
Justin Harrell: Packers, 2007
Dick Weeks: Brewers, 2003
***NOTE***
Robert Traylor and Shawn Respert don't appear on this list because they weren't actual draft picks of the Bucks, they were acquired via trades.
10. Marcus Haislip

Drafted 13th overall in the 2002 NBA Draft, Haislip was supposed to fill the power forward void the Bucks had been missing for quite some time, the same void Anthony Mason wasn't filling.
Instead Haislip turned out to be more of a tweener. Not strong enough to excel in the post, but not quite gifted enough or a capable enough shooter to play on the wing. Haislip was eventually released in 2004, and by 2005 he was headed to Europe, where apparetnly he still plays to this day.
9. Jerry Reynolds

Ahh the Iceman, Jerry "Ice" Reynolds, not to be confused with Jamal Reynolds...foreshadowing? The 22nd overall pick in the 1985 NBA draft, Ice never averaged more than 8 points per game in his time in Milwaukee, and was gone by 1988, or so we thought. The Bucks somehow decided to bring him back for a second tour of duty in 1995. I got the chance to see that Reynolds play in a handful of games, man was he awful.
8. Todd Day and Lee Mayberry

The Arkansas teammate were both selected by the Bucks in the 1992 NBA Draft, and neither lived up to potential. While neither of the two were awful (Day actually averaged 16 ppg), they never turned into what Milwaukee thought they were getting. Mayberry was an adequate backup point guard and Day was best served as a scorer off the bench. Only problem was Milwaukee asked them both to start. With the same picks the Bucks used in that draft to get these two, they could have nabbed Robert Horry and Latrell Spreewell. Uggghhhhhhhhh.
7. JM Gold

Injuries, un-tapped potential and more injuries sum up JM Gold in a nut shell. Taken as the 13th overall pick in the 1998 amatuer draft, Gold was supposed to be the team's ace of the future. During his six seasons in the Brewers organization, the highest level Gold reached was high A ball, and in his final three seasons he sported an era higher than 6.60.
After the 2003 season, the Brewers cut the cord on JM Gold. He hasn't appeared in any organization since.
6. Green Bay Packers 2004 NFL Draft

Yes, I'm tossing this whole draft up there. How can you pick just one from the draft that gave us: Grabby Smurf (Ahmad Carroll), Joey Thomas, Donnell Washington, B.J. Sander and then inexplicably Corey Williams and Scott Wells. Todd and I are both convinced either Mike Sherman slept through those last two picks, thought the draft was over, or just didn't care. How else do you explain those two being a part of the same group?
Off subject a little bit too, but Mike Sherman hands in this draft (and numerous other personnel decisions like this) and yet Ted Thompson is the vilain and worst GM in Packers History? Sure.
Carroll and Thomas were both awful, Joey Thomas actually beat out Ahmad Carroll in camp, but turned into a turd himself, Donnell Washington was always hurt and just plain dumb, and B.J. Sander...there are no words to explain him. Not only did these guys suck, but they were turds as well.
5. John Michels

John Michels is the reason why you always need to have multiple plans heading into the draft. The Packers were absolutely in love with Miami linebacker Ray Lewis and had every intention of taking him. Only one problem, Baltimore snatched him one pick before them, so Ron Wolf panicked and took Michels.
Drafted as the heir apparent to Ken Ruettgers, Michels looked the part of a quality tackle his rookie season. At least for the first half. Michels took over for the injured Ruettgers and played relatively well, earning First Team All Rookie honors.
For as strong as Michels start was, his finish was equally horrendous. He became an awful tackle, seemingly overnight, and was eventually replaced by journeyman lineman and Abdullah the Butcher look-alike, Bruce Wilkerson.
Michels would spend the rest of his time in Green Bay doing one of the following: being injured, recovering from injuries, or sucking. He was eventually traded to the Eagles in 1999 for turd defensive end, Jon Harris
4. Jamal Reynolds

The next great outside speed rusher from Florida State...hold on for a second. While Reynolds may have been that, how many of these FSU rush ends transitioned well into the Pros? Reinard Wilson? Andre Wadsworth? Peter Boulware is the most successful (now that I say that I know I'm missing somebaody) and even he had a short lived career. But I digress.
Reynolds was an undersized speed rusher. He was extremely raw, looked lost and confused all the time and lacked any confidence what so ever. He was probably best suited to be an outside linebacker, but he had zero coverage skills. Oh, and did I mention he was selected 10th overall after the Packers traded Matt Hasselback and their 17th pick to the Seahawks for the 10th choice?
Reynolds was cut after just two seasons in Green Bay, not before they tried to trade him to the Colts, but true to form, Reynolds failed his physical. Eventually he was released and scooped up by the Browns...only to be cut shortly after again. Reynolds was Ron Wolf's last first round pick and will forever be remembered as Wolf's worst draft pick. Want more salt in the wound? The Seahawks used the 17th pick that we traded to them, along with Matt Hasselback, to select Steve Hutchinson.
Kill me now.
3. Kent Benson

The first overall pick in the 1977 NBA Draft, the Indiana center was a beast in college, helping lead the Hoisers to the 1975-76 NCAA Championship.
Benson's time in Milwaukee was short lived, spending just three seasons in Brew Town and never averaging more than 12 points or 7 boards per game. While the BTB isn't actually old enough to have seen Benson in action, man did I hear numerous stories about this guy, particularly how much he sucked, from relatives. His lone bright spot in Milwaukee was being part of the trade that brought Bob Lainer to town.
2. Antone Williamson

Who could forget Sal Bando's all-time favorite player? Williamson was a third baseman at Bando's alma matter, ASU, and had an incredible College World Series.
Drafted third overall in 1994, Williamson was a guy with holes in his swing and an absolute butcher defensively (maybe it's not a recent trend only for Brewers draft picks), but Bando loved him. Williamson was awful. He only played in 24 games for the Crew, batting just .204 with ZERO homers and SIX RBIs in his time in Milwaukee. AWESOME!
Wanna know just how bad he was? Try searching Wikipedia or google for the guy...good luck, you'll get the same two or three baseball-reference pages.
1. Tony Mandarich

Was there any doubt? The Packers finished 1988 with a 4-12 record, winning their final two games. Those last two wins would cost them the number one overall pick in April's 1989 NFL Draft (Dallas finished 3-13, losing their final game of the season) and any chance at getting Troy Aikman. While on the surface that would be a bad thing, lets not forget the Brett Favre era never happens if Troy Aikman is a Packer.
Mandarich was taken second overall, ahead of (in order)Barry Sanders, Derrick Thomas and Deion Sanders. Any of those would have been nice. We all know how much of colossal failure he was, spending his first season on special teams, and finally being released after three years.
Mandarich made a comeback in the mid/late-90's with the Colts, and actually resurfaced to as a capable lineman, but the damage was done. The "Incredible Bulk" will forever go down as the biggest bust in Packers, Wisconsin, and arguably NFL history.


